Skip to main content
Area 51

Return to Question

replaced http://discuss.area51.stackexchange.com/ with https://area51.meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link
Community Bot
Community Bot
  • 401

Answers, especially Islamic answers are authentic only when a proper reference from the Holy Qur'an and Hadith, or any other scripture is given in support.

Reason: A question can be answered by any one in any way. So answers with personal opinions and whims are sure to be given by people since SE is open to all. In Islam, an answer is 100% authentic and acceptable if it says what God and his messenger(pbuh) say. If any answer is given with reference to a scripture, it should be classified from the other answers. Also If possible, answerers can be awarded extra reputation for this.

There is a similar question here: http://discuss.area51.stackexchange.com/questions/2673/islam-only-answers-with-references-to-credible-sources-should-be-allowed-in-thiIslam: Only answers with references to credible sources should be allowed in this site otherwise they'll be chaos. But it is way too strict for Stack Exchange.

Proposal: Islam

Answers, especially Islamic answers are authentic only when a proper reference from the Holy Qur'an and Hadith, or any other scripture is given in support.

Reason: A question can be answered by any one in any way. So answers with personal opinions and whims are sure to be given by people since SE is open to all. In Islam, an answer is 100% authentic and acceptable if it says what God and his messenger(pbuh) say. If any answer is given with reference to a scripture, it should be classified from the other answers. Also If possible, answerers can be awarded extra reputation for this.

There is a similar question here: http://discuss.area51.stackexchange.com/questions/2673/islam-only-answers-with-references-to-credible-sources-should-be-allowed-in-thi. But it is way too strict for Stack Exchange.

Proposal: Islam

Answers, especially Islamic answers are authentic only when a proper reference from the Holy Qur'an and Hadith, or any other scripture is given in support.

Reason: A question can be answered by any one in any way. So answers with personal opinions and whims are sure to be given by people since SE is open to all. In Islam, an answer is 100% authentic and acceptable if it says what God and his messenger(pbuh) say. If any answer is given with reference to a scripture, it should be classified from the other answers. Also If possible, answerers can be awarded extra reputation for this.

There is a similar question here: Islam: Only answers with references to credible sources should be allowed in this site otherwise they'll be chaos. But it is way too strict for Stack Exchange.

Proposal: Islam

edited title
Link
Tabrez Ahmed
Tabrez Ahmed
  • 435
  • 2
  • 7

Encourage answers with reference from Qur'an, hadith or any other scripture by classifying them from othersnon-referenced ones

Source Link
Tabrez Ahmed
Tabrez Ahmed
  • 435
  • 2
  • 7

Encourage answers with reference from Qur'an, hadith or any other scripture by classifying them from others

Answers, especially Islamic answers are authentic only when a proper reference from the Holy Qur'an and Hadith, or any other scripture is given in support.

Reason: A question can be answered by any one in any way. So answers with personal opinions and whims are sure to be given by people since SE is open to all. In Islam, an answer is 100% authentic and acceptable if it says what God and his messenger(pbuh) say. If any answer is given with reference to a scripture, it should be classified from the other answers. Also If possible, answerers can be awarded extra reputation for this.

There is a similar question here: http://discuss.area51.stackexchange.com/questions/2673/islam-only-answers-with-references-to-credible-sources-should-be-allowed-in-thi. But it is way too strict for Stack Exchange.

Proposal: Islam