Skip to main content
replaced http://meta.boardgames.stackexchange.com/ with https://boardgames.meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Proposal: Poker

Poker questions can be very specific, so I was wondering whether or not it is appropriate to allow arbitrarily detailed questions or would they be considered "too localized." For instance, the following question has a score of 10 from the definition phase:

KK on the button. Raised PF, was check raised on J75 rainbow flop. What's my line?

I'm assuming that such a question would also include tags to indicate which poker game (e.g. Texas Hold'em), the stakes (e.g. $1/$2), the betting structure (no-limit, pot-limit, or fixed-limit), that it's a ring game (as opposed to a tournament game), and perhaps whether it's online or live.

Of course comments can ask for further details (e.g. how much was the raise or what information is known about the opponent).

It has been hintedhinted that such detail would not be appropriate on the board games site.

Proposal: Poker

Poker questions can be very specific, so I was wondering whether or not it is appropriate to allow arbitrarily detailed questions or would they be considered "too localized." For instance, the following question has a score of 10 from the definition phase:

KK on the button. Raised PF, was check raised on J75 rainbow flop. What's my line?

I'm assuming that such a question would also include tags to indicate which poker game (e.g. Texas Hold'em), the stakes (e.g. $1/$2), the betting structure (no-limit, pot-limit, or fixed-limit), that it's a ring game (as opposed to a tournament game), and perhaps whether it's online or live.

Of course comments can ask for further details (e.g. how much was the raise or what information is known about the opponent).

It has been hinted that such detail would not be appropriate on the board games site.

Proposal: Poker

Poker questions can be very specific, so I was wondering whether or not it is appropriate to allow arbitrarily detailed questions or would they be considered "too localized." For instance, the following question has a score of 10 from the definition phase:

KK on the button. Raised PF, was check raised on J75 rainbow flop. What's my line?

I'm assuming that such a question would also include tags to indicate which poker game (e.g. Texas Hold'em), the stakes (e.g. $1/$2), the betting structure (no-limit, pot-limit, or fixed-limit), that it's a ring game (as opposed to a tournament game), and perhaps whether it's online or live.

Of course comments can ask for further details (e.g. how much was the raise or what information is known about the opponent).

It has been hinted that such detail would not be appropriate on the board games site.

Source Link

How specific should poker questions be without being "too localized"?

Proposal: Poker

Poker questions can be very specific, so I was wondering whether or not it is appropriate to allow arbitrarily detailed questions or would they be considered "too localized." For instance, the following question has a score of 10 from the definition phase:

KK on the button. Raised PF, was check raised on J75 rainbow flop. What's my line?

I'm assuming that such a question would also include tags to indicate which poker game (e.g. Texas Hold'em), the stakes (e.g. $1/$2), the betting structure (no-limit, pot-limit, or fixed-limit), that it's a ring game (as opposed to a tournament game), and perhaps whether it's online or live.

Of course comments can ask for further details (e.g. how much was the raise or what information is known about the opponent).

It has been hinted that such detail would not be appropriate on the board games site.