11 votes
Accepted

Quais tipos de pergunta devem ser evitados?

O conteúdo das perguntas vai depender fundamentalmente das dúvidas dos utilizadores que coloquem as questões e, indirectamente, dos que derem as respostas. Numa primeira fase não convirá muito ...
5 votes

Can we add a custom close reason specific to Area 51?

This unravels a general discoverability problem inherent to what Area 51 is about. On the one hand, you want your example questions to show there's enough unique content to justify the creation of a ...
5 votes
Accepted

Why were these questions closed in Defintion?

You are correct that some of these questions may not technically be closed as an "exact duplicate" on the actual site — but for the purpose of presenting the strongest possible Definition for ...
4 votes

Why were these questions closed in Defintion?

Few suggestions. Question: What programming languages can I use to create a smart contract? It's a list question, see: What is the definition of a list question? These kind of questions are ...
  • 4,688
4 votes

Should financial/investment topics be considered off-topic on the newly proposed Cryptocurrency SE site?

They should be off-topic for two primary reasons: There is no mathematical formula for investing, so any information given is an opinion. Whether or not an investment is safe will also be opinion as ...
4 votes

Should financial/investment topics be considered off-topic on the newly proposed Cryptocurrency SE site?

I think it should be off-topic. Questions about HOW to buy/sell/transfer/use some cryptocurrency would be on-topic, but WHY to buy/sell or strategies to buy/sell would not be. Discussing investment ...
3 votes

Lengthen the aging period of close votes on example questions or get rid of it altogether

I'm not sure that lengthening would really help the situation much. The level of activity of each proposal can vary and you don't want to have a situation where 5 people with close vote permissions ...
2 votes
Accepted

How to interpret closing my question?

Per your flag, I have un-deleted that post. That post was removed inadvertently when one of the linked proposals expired and the underlying discussions were cleaned up. Sorry about the confusion.
1 vote

Should I ask off-topic questions?

According to the text above, I should ask off-topic. No, that's not what it says. It says if you're not sure whether a question would be off-topic or not, you should ask it. If you're skeptical about ...
  • 1,002
1 vote

One of the off-topic reasons on discuss.A51 has a fatal wording error

The discussion zone is a forum for discussing proposed sites. While it uses the same Q&A format, the meta side of Area51 (or any site) is not a site of it's own. This close reason is used when ...

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible