Here is a list of registered users who think they have committed to the Mathematica proposal but who are not showing up in the list of committers that I can see.

  1. Sal Mangano (registered version)
  2. Pillsy (registered version)
  3. Markus Roellig

(Sal and Pillsy previously committed as unregistered and have obviously been trying to rectify this.)

It is not obvious enough to new Area 51 users that their commitment only counts if they have confirmed their email address. Strangely, the commitment screen asks for your real name but not your email address, and it does not say anything about needing to confirm your email address before your commitment counts.

enter image description here

(I just selected a random proposal I wasn't already committed to, to show this)

Please add some suitable BIG BOLD text to the commitment screen along the lines of "You must confirm your email address for the commitment to take effect. Please check your spam-catcher if you do not receive the email shortly.".

Right now many "commitments" are meaningless, unbeknowst to the user.

Proposal: Mathematica

1 Answer 1


Also see: You won't be Committed if you don't confirm your email

which tells of at least 4 people from the Genealogy & Family History proposal who also thought they were committed but were not.

I agree the form should say something stronger, like: "You will not be committed until you confirm your email" and the commitment should not show up on their profile until they do.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .