I strongly believe that there should be separate QAs for all the different disciplines in engineering rather than a single QA for them all. I shall briefly list out my reasons :
- On successful launch, this QA would consist of a chaotic mix of questions from more than 5 or 7 different disciplines.
- Technically only less than a fifth of the total users would be able to relate to a question. And very few of these would be able to even answer it.
- A student or professional from a particular discipline will not be interested in most of the questions on the QA unrelated to his/her discipline.
I would rather that each and every discipline have its own QA. I strongly believe that each discipline can have a healthy QA with very active users. Do the pros outweigh these evident cons? Or should this proposal be closed?