For the Proposal of Mythology.

Should the person who started a proposal automatically become a moderator? If I make a proposal I want it to be a website in which I and others feel comfortable.

  • 12
    Why do you need to be a moderator for it to be a website in which you feel comfortable?
    – JohnB
    Commented Aug 20, 2013 at 21:57
  • 4
    This is more a general meta question than a Mythology-specific question. I might look/ask on meta.stackoverflow.com instead of on here.
    – kuwaly
    Commented Aug 20, 2013 at 23:08

2 Answers 2


I do not think so. There should be nothing automatic about moderator selection. If it were set up that way, the system could too easily be gamed. The mod tools provide too much access to a lot of personal information for moderators to be automatically designated.

  • 7
    I agree. Moderators are selected on their merits — to handle the responsibility and do the job well. Suggesting the site idea doesn't necessarily qualify them to be a moderator. Commented Aug 21, 2013 at 15:30

Other than what John pointed out, there are a lot of other reasons too.

  • Proposal creators disappear many a time after creating the proposal.

  • Other users have a greater impact on the proposal than the creator by bringing in new followers, sharing, and spreading the word.

  • Many users come together, discuss, debate, explore and then clearly define the actual scope of the site. The creator essentially threw out two lines on the internet at large. It is these individuals who turned that line into a scope and possibly viable site.

  • Proposals rarely go out into beta in the same form in which they were initially suggested.

So, a big


The contributions of a proposal creator are rarely deserving of a moderator position on the beta site. In the cases that they are, then we dont really need this discussion at all.

(Dont forget, the creator gets a significant rep bump of >1k rep for a proposal going to beta, if recognition was a reason that motivated you to suggest this)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .